होमAsian CricketRs27.309 per Unit in Nepra's Dock: Who Bowled the No-Ball in Pakistan's Power Tariff?
Asian Cricket

Rs27.309 per Unit in Nepra's Dock: Who Bowled the No-Ball in Pakistan's Power Tariff?

**मुख्य उत्तर (≤60 शब्द):** नेप्रा के समक्ष CPPA-G ने CY2027 के लिए औसत पावर परचेज प्राइस 27.309 रुपये प्रति यूनिट प्रस्तावित की है, जो अभी अंतिम टैरिफ नहीं है। बेस केस में कैपेसिटी चार्ज 14.717 रुपये प्रति यूनिट और ईंधन लागत 10.141 रुपये प्रति यूनिट है। **मुख्य तथ्य:** - बेस केस की कुल पावर परचेज लागत 3.552 ट्रिलियन रुपये; ईंधन 1.319 ट्रिलियन, कैपेसिटी चार्जेज 1.914 ट्रिलियन रुपये। - सर्वोत्तम परिदृश्य 25.883 रुपये प्रति यूनिट; सबसे प्रतिकूल 28.835–29.255 रुपये प्रति यूनिट। - प्रोजेक्टेड बिक्री 130,081 GWh; बेस केस मांग वृद्धि 2.6 प्रतिशत। - नेप्रा ने KIBOR 11.70 से 12 प्रतिशत करने का आदेश दिया; टैरिफ रीबेसिंग 1 जनवरी 2027 से। **स्रोत:** नेप्रा की सार्वजनिक सुनवाई और CPPA-G का CY2027 पावर परचेज प्राइस रिपोर्ट। तिथि: फरवरी 2026 के नेप्रा आदेश के अनुसार। | Cross-checked: cricsultan.com **संबंधित प्रश्न-उत्तर:** Q: क्या 8 प्रतिशत की बढ़ोतरी तय हो गई है? A: नहीं, यह CPPA-G का प्रस्ताव है जो नेप्रा की समीक्षा के अधीन है और अंतिम उपभोक्ता टैरिफ नहीं है। Q: सबसे बड़ी लागत कौन सी है? A: कैपेसिटी चार्ज 14.717 रुपये प्रति यूनिट के साथ सबसे बड़ी मद है और कम ईंधन कीमत पर भी स्थिर रहता है। Q: उद्योग ने क्या मांगा? A: उद्योग प्रतिनिधियों ने इंक्रीमेंटल पैकेज निलंबित करने और FCA को भविष्य के लिए स्थिर करने की मांग की।

A story about a rising electricity bill usually arrives as a single number — 'an eight per cent increase' — and vanishes from the front page the next morning. But what came before Nepra (National Electric Power Regulatory Authority) in Islamabad last week was, in effect, a scorecard: the Central Power Purchasing Agency (CPPA-G) six-scenario Power Purchase Price projection for CY2027, whose base case sits at Rs27.309 per unit. That is the number that will set the average consumer's next electricity price. I rewound the hearing documents the way I rewind a reviewed wicket frame by frame — and the first thing visible was not the increase but the fixed architecture of capacity charges that does not fall even when fuel gets cheaper.

To read this hearing, hold three dates and one ratio. The dates: the day of the public hearing, Nepra's order, and January 1, 2027, from which tariff rebasing applies. The ratio is this: the projection has two components — fuel cost, which moves with the market, and capacity charges, which are owed to Independent Power Producers (IPPs) whether or not electricity is generated. CPPA-G's base-case total power purchase cost is Rs3.552 trillion, of which fuel cost is Rs1.319 trillion and capacity charges Rs1.914 trillion. Capacity charges work out to Rs14.717 per unit, larger than the base-case fuel component of Rs10.141 per unit. Meaning: the fattest slice of the bill is the part demand cannot touch.

Rs27.309 per Unit in Nepra's Dock: Who Bowled the No-Ball in Pakistan's Power Tariff?

Count the scenarios and the picture sharpens. The best case — Rs25.883 per unit — requires cheap fuel and a favourable RLNG-gas mix. The worst case runs to Rs28.835–29.255 per unit, on an assumed exchange rate of Rs290 to the dollar. The spread between the two ends is about Rs3.4 per unit. But note: even in the best case, capacity charges stay at Rs1.914 trillion. All the fuel savings shrink against this one line item. That is the least-discussed and most important fact in the whole debate.

The questions Nepra raised at the hearing were good and investigative in nature. It sought clarification on the gap between CPPA-G, ISMO and Disco demand forecasts. It ordered KIBOR revised from 11.70 per cent to 12 per cent. It questioned RLNG supply, the dollar rate and Brent prices. Base case assumes 2.6 per cent demand growth, while the sensitivity scenario drops to 0.70 per cent with no load management assumed. Here is the technical trap few catch. The capacity charge amount is fixed, but the fewer units it is spread across, the higher the per-unit cost. If a higher tariff suppresses industrial and household consumption, per-unit capacity cost climbs further — the tariff increase can work in reverse. If actual sales fall short of the projected 130,081 GWh, the Rs14.717 visible today could sit above Rs15 next year.

This is where industry's objection must be recorded, because it is not merely noise. Industry representatives demanded immediate suspension of the incremental package and prospective stabilisation of FCAs (fuel charges adjustments). Their argument: the package benefits only a few industries and loads a cross-subsidy burden on more than 90 per cent of consumers. They warn FCAs could rise two to three times in winter. That warning looks less alarming on paper than it does once the capacity-charge structure is examined. If fixed costs are fixed and sales are uncertain, volatility is not an accident — it is the structure's own result.

Rs27.309 per Unit in Nepra's Dock: Who Bowled the No-Ball in Pakistan's Power Tariff?

The temptation here is to reach for an inverted conclusion: that the government is raising tariffs to save industry, or that the whole exercise is a staged drama. I won't say that, because the record shows nothing of the kind. What the record shows is that Nepra did not reject the assumptions; it challenged them, forced a KIBOR change, and demanded scenario analysis. That is a healthy regulatory process. What the record does not show is any explanation to consumers of how much of the eight per cent is capacity charge and how much is fuel. The hearing was open, but the interpretation of the numbers did not reach the ordinary citizen the way a recurring broadcast graphic does. Nepra's scrutiny is directionally right; its communication strategy is not.

Four things to track from here. The dollar rate — any sustained move between 279 and 290 feeds straight into fuel and financing costs. RLNG and Brent prices. The gap between actual sales and the 130,081 GWh projection. And any movement on capacity-payment reform in IPP contracts. As long as capacity charges sit near Rs1.914 trillion, cheaper fuel will offer relief, not relief. The day that line item moves, Pakistan's electricity bill will genuinely move — everything else is an argument about a no-ball the camera keeps showing and nobody is watching.

संबंधित खिलाड़ी